The Truth About Physiological Testing in Endurance Sport (And Why So Much of What You’re Being Sold Is Noise)

Also on Substack: read this article there or subscribe to get new articles by email.

If you’re an endurance athlete on social media, you’ve been told a lot of things lately. Your watch knows your VO2 max. A lactate finger-prick can tell you exactly how many grams of fat versus carbohydrate you’re burning per hour. A clip-on mask you bought online can replace a lab. Somewhere in the scroll, a coach with 40,000 followers has confidently explained all of it — and most of it isn’t true.

At Performance Evolution, we test athletes for a living. Not for content, not for a reel, but because the data changes how people train and how they perform. So we want to lay out, plainly, what we think is happening in this space right now — and why we do things the way we do.

1. Everyone’s an expert now

Physiology is complicated. Metabolic testing, threshold determination, gas exchange kinetics — these are areas built on decades of exercise science, and they don’t compress well into a 60-second video. But confidence sells better than nuance, so we’re seeing coaches, amateurs, influencers, and even professional athletes speak with total certainty about physiological concepts they haven’t actually been trained to interpret. The result is a huge amount of misinformation dressed up as expertise, and athletes making training decisions based on it.

The Truth About Physiological Testing in Endurance Sport (And Why So Much of What You’re Being Sold Is Noise)

2. Your wearable is a good pacer, not a physiologist

Garmin, Coros, Apple Watch — these are excellent tools for tracking training load, heart rate trends, and pace. What they are not is an accurate window into your physiology. VO2 max estimates from wrist-based optical sensors are algorithmic guesses derived from heart rate and pace data, not measured oxygen consumption. Treat them as a rough trend indicator over time, not a physiological fact.

3. Lactate testing has a role — but not the one it’s being sold for

We use lactate testing. It has genuine value in tracking training adaptation over time. What it cannot do is tell you your fat versus carbohydrate oxidation rates. A blood lactate concentration is a signal of the balance between lactate production and clearance — it is not a direct measure of substrate use. Companies like InSycd market lactate-based “metabolic efficiency” or fuel-mix outputs as if they’re precise substrate breakdowns. They aren’t, and there is no validated physiological method that gets you there from a lactate sample alone. Charging athletes for that framing isn’t a grey area — it’s selling certainty the science doesn’t support.

4. The VO2 Master: a step up, but still a partial picture

The VO2 Master gets some credit for one thing: it’s portable, so you can test in the environment that actually matters — on the road, on the bike, on the trail — rather than being confined to a treadmill in a lab. That ecological validity is genuinely useful.

But that’s where the credit ends. It only measures oxygen consumption. It doesn’t capture carbon dioxide output at all, which means it has exactly the same blind spot as lactate testing when it comes to metabolic or substrate information — it simply arrives there by a different route. No CO2 data means no RER, no substrate use, no real metabolic picture, whatever the marketing implies. There are also unresolved, legitimate questions in the field around its calibration consistency across different conditions and intensities, which matters a great deal if you’re using the numbers to make training decisions. It’s a step up on a lactate meter for portability. It is not a substitute for proper gas exchange analysis.

5. If you want the full picture, you need breath-by-breath gas exchange

This is the actual gold standard, and it’s what we use. Breath-by-breath analysis measures both oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production continuously, which is what allows genuine calculation of substrate utilisation, ventilatory thresholds, and respiratory efficiency — not estimates, not proxies.

6. It’s validated, and it gives you a genuinely useful dataset

This isn’t experimental kit. Breath-by-breath metabolic testing is the method used in exercise physiology research worldwide, and it produces a dense, reliable dataset: VO2, VCO2, respiratory exchange ratio, ventilation, breathing frequency, heart rate, and derived threshold points, all mapped together across an effort.

7. It’s about far more than VO2 max

Yes, you get an accurate VO2 max. But that’s arguably the least useful number in the file. What actually moves performance is:

– **Accurate threshold identification** — so your training zones are built on your physiology, not a generic percentage of max heart rate.

– **Exercise economy** — how efficiently you move at a given speed or power, which lets us compare different trainers, bike positions, or set-ups. This matters because performance isn’t only about watts — it’s about the speed you can sustainably hold.

– **Fatigue resistance and environmental resilience** — how your system holds up under prolonged load or in heat, which most testing never touches at all.

Put together, you get an unmatched view of respiratory, metabolic, and cardiovascular function, and that view tells us where an athlete’s genuine limiter actually is — rather than guessing.

8. The cost argument doesn’t hold up anymore

There’s a lingering perception that this kind of testing is expensive and hard to access. That was fair a decade ago. It isn’t now. And when you weigh it against what’s being charged for far less rigorous alternatives — we’ve seen InSycd-style lactate testing priced around £225 for a service that fundamentally cannot deliver the metabolic insight it implies — proper gas exchange testing isn’t the expensive option. It’s the one that actually pays you back in training direction.

9. Data without interpretation is just numbers

The output is only as good as the person reading it. A trained practitioner doesn’t just hand you a printout — they translate the data into a training direction: which system is holding you back, whether it’s metabolic, respiratory, or cardiovascular, and what specific work raises that ceiling. That’s the difference between a test and a testing service.

10. Train on evidence, not on what looks good

Influencer-led shortcuts are everywhere in this sport right now, and a lot of them are polished, confident, and wrong. Our view is simple: test properly, interpret honestly, and train the limiter that’s actually holding you back — not the one that makes a better infographic.

11. This isn’t just for athletes anymore

Everything above has been framed around performance, and that’s where this kind of testing started. But breath-by-breath gas exchange data is quietly becoming one of the most useful tools in general fitness and wellbeing too, and we think that shift deserves attention.

– **Resting metabolic rate (RMR)** — measured directly rather than estimated from a formula based on age, weight, and sex — gives a genuinely accurate baseline for calorie needs, which changes what “eat less, move more” advice actually means for a given person.

– **FatMax testing** — identifying the exact intensity at which someone burns the highest rate of fat as fuel — is directly useful for dietary and weight-management goals, not just endurance pacing.

– **Longevity training** — using thresholds and metabolic data to build the kind of zone 2 and mixed-intensity conditioning that the longevity and healthspan research increasingly points to as protective.

– **Respiratory conditioning** — understanding someone’s breathing efficiency and ventilatory response isn’t just a performance lever, it’s a marker of general cardiorespiratory health and a target for training in its own right.

In short, this stops being a niche endurance-sport tool and becomes a fitness and wellbeing tool with a much wider audience — anyone who wants their training or their diet built on their own physiology rather than a population average.

  1. What we actually use: the KORR CardioCoach Pro

Everything we’ve described above, we deliver using the KORR CardioCoach Pro. It’s a breath-by-breath metabolic analyser, and critically, it’s independently validated — its accuracy has been assessed against the Douglas bag method (the historical gold standard for gas exchange measurement) in peer-reviewed research, not just manufacturer claims. That independent verification matters. It’s the difference between trusting a number because a company printed it and trusting a number because it’s been checked against the reference standard by people with no commercial stake in the answer.

—

**Coming up:** over the next few months we’re going to break down each of our primary physiological tests individually — what they measure, how we use them, and why understanding your own physiology matters more for your performance than another shiny new bike or another pair of supershoes. That’s the whole idea behind Performance Evolution: your engine, understood properly, is the upgrade that actually compounds.

*Performance Evolution provides breath-by-breath physiological testing for endurance athletes. If you want to know what’s actually limiting your performance, get in touch.*

Read and subscribe on Substack

This article is also on the Group Evolution Substack. Subscribe there to get each new article by email as it is published.

Read on Substack Subscribe on Substack